Find 3 sources of information, advice, or tutorials online and review them.
I looked at answers to the question “How to Illustrate a Children’s Book?” The three sources I found were YouTube, and the two blogs Artists & Illustrators and Creative Bloq.
Technology changes very rapidly, how current is the information you found?
The YouTube video was from January 21, 2014. Creative Bloq’s post was published on February 25, 2022. Artists & Illustrators’ post was from September 8, 2011. The initial search gave me information from varying times, but the most recent results were closer to the top of the page than others.
Who is posting the information? Are they an authority on the matter? How can you tell?
The sources were made and published by users either on their blogs or YouTube channel. Each article or video was from an authority on illustration. The channel is organized by a professional illustrator who explained her personal experience and process of illustrating. The blogs were either written by journalists who interviewed a professional illustrator or by the illustrator themselves.
What types of gatekeeping mechanisms are in place for the source you found? (i.e., is there an editor or are posts up/downvoted democratically?)
YouTube as a platform has Terms of Service and community guidelines for what is and isn’t allowed to be posted on its site. Individual channels may have editors to help them put the video together but there is also a system of viewers liking or disliking videos to tell others whether or not the information is helpful. The blog sites are big and set up like news sites with editors and journalists creating the posts.
Discuss the quality of the information. Is it well-written, clear, and easy to follow?
All the information was of high quality and easy to understand. The information was clear and helpful for the question being asked.
Finally, is this a resource you might use in the future, and if so, why?
YouTube is a great resource that I would use in the future to find tutorials on something I am interested in or just an explanation of something I don’t understand. Blogs can be a great source of reliable information with references and professionals but you need to double-check their sources and make sure they are truly reliable.
Sources:
https://www.creativebloq.com/features/how-to-illustrate-a-childrens-book